NASDAQ: SIGI

Selective Insurance (SIGI) Stock Analysis & Forecast

Nov 13 close

$102.67−0.69 (−0.7%)

Gekko Brief

AI summaryNov 9 close

Selective Insurance's stock has drawn attention this week following strong third-quarter earnings, a 12% increase in its common dividend, and a new $200 million share buyback program. The stock touched a 52-week high of $101.28 on 3 November, with coverage noting it had risen 17.5% over the past month and 20.4% year-to-date. Separate commentary described the shares as reasonably priced on earnings support, citing a P/E ratio of approximately 11.7x, while another piece weighed whether the stock's premium to the industry is still justified given catastrophe-loss and cost risks.

SIGI closes at $100.49, up 1.1%, sitting above both its 50-day ($90.68) and 200-day ($88.15) moving averages, with the 50-day above the 200-day. The GekkoIndex reads 49.4, placing it in the Neutral zone. Price sits 4.8% above Gekko Fair Value of $95.85. One-month return stands at 19.3%, three-month at 6.9%, and one-year at 30.3%, against a 52-week range of $72.78 to $105.65.

The next earnings date falls on 4 February 2027, 86 days out, beyond a typical 20-trading-day hold. No insider, Congress, or unusual options activity appears in the current windows. Seasonality shows a 20-day average of -0.6% over 5 years, with gains in 2 of those years. Consensus among 6 firms shows 2 buy, 3 hold, and 1 sell, with a target of $103.86 implying 3.4% upside.

Written by AI from the Nov 9, 2026 close and checked automatically against the figures on this page.

Selective Insurance price vs fair value

$102.67$96.48Nov ’25May ’26Nov ’26
Close $102.67200-day averageGekko Fair Value $96.48

Selective Insurance quick facts

Market cap
$6.12B
P/E ratio
12.4
Forward P/E
11.4
EPS, TTM
$8.32
Revenue, TTM
$5.44B
Profit margin
9.4%
Dividend yield
1.67%
Beta
0.21
Volume
312,462 avg 587,142
1-year return
+29.8%
Typical daily move
±2.4%
Typical 20-day move
±4.1%
50-day average
$91.56
200-day average
$88.57
Next earnings
Feb 4 before open
Shares outstanding
59.57M
52-week range
$72.78$105.65

Selective Insurance swing-trade checklist

Selective Insurance scores 2 supportive, 2 mixed and 1 headwind across the 5 checklist items with data.

Six things swing traders check before a 20-day hold, read from the latest data.

2 supportive2 mixed1 headwind

  • Trendsupportive

    Above 50 and 200-day

    Close $102.67 is above the 50-day ($91.56) and 200-day ($88.57) averages, and the 50-day is above the 200-day.

    See the chart
  • GekkoIndexmixed

    50, Neutral

    Reading 50 is in the Neutral zone.

    See the GekkoIndex
  • Fair valueheadwind

    6.4% above

    Price is 6.4% above Gekko Fair Value (more than 5% above).

    See fair value
  • Smart moneyno data

    No data

    No insider, Congress or unusual options activity in the window.

    See smart money
  • Earnings risksupportive

    Reports in 81 days

    Next report Feb 4, 2027, 81 days away — outside a typical 20-trading-day hold.

    See earnings
  • Seasonalitymixed

    +0.4% on average

    From this point in the calendar, the next 20 trading days averaged +0.4% over 5 years, rising in 2 of them.

    See seasonality

A description of current data, not a recommendation. How this page works

Selective Insurance stock chart and price history

Selective Insurance closed at $102.67 on Nov 13, 2026, +29.8% over the past year, inside a 52-week range of $72.78 to $105.65.

Close50-day average200-day averageVolume
Selective Insurance share price, past year, with 50-day and 200-day moving averages and volume$80$90$100DecJan 2026FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNov102.67

Use the left and right arrow keys to read daily values.

Performance Breakdown

1 month
+17.6%
3 months
+11.5%
6 months
+16.4%
1 year
+29.8%
The full SIGI chart adds GekkoIndex, insider, options, Congress and hedge fund markers, plus TrendCandles™.Open SIGI in Gekko

Follow Selective Insurance through every session

Put SIGI on a Gekko watchlist and see its GekkoIndex, Gekko Fair Value and smart money signals update on the chart as they change.

Track SIGI in GekkoFree for 7 days. No credit card required.

About Selective Insurance

Selective Insurance provides a range of insurance coverage to businesses, government bodies, nonprofits and individual policyholders across the United States. Its offerings span property protection against damage to buildings and belongings, casualty coverage for workplace injuries and third-party liability claims, and flood insurance, giving it a presence across several lines of personal and commercial risk.

The company organizes its work into four main areas: standard commercial lines, standard personal lines, excess and surplus lines, and an investments segment that manages the capital generated from underwriting. That investment arm holds a mix of fixed income securities, commercial mortgage loans, equities and alternative assets. Selective reaches its customers not through direct sales but through independent retail agents and wholesale general agents who distribute its policies.

Founded in 1926, Selective Insurance is headquartered in Branchville, New Jersey. Its shares trade on the NASDAQ under the ticker SIGI.

Listed
NASDAQ
Sector
Finance
Industry
Property/Casualty insurance
Website
selective.com

Selective Insurance GekkoIndex: the smart money zone

Selective Insurance’s GekkoIndex — Gekko’s 0 to 100 smart money score — reads 50, in the Neutral zone, up 1.4 points over five sessions.

010050Neutral

Up 1.4 points over five sessions.

Reading for Nov 13, 2026

What followed past readings in each zone

ZoneReadings5 days10 days20 days50 days
Buying34+0.1%+0.3%+6.2%+12.2%
Accumulation262+0.9%+1.0%+0.7%+0.2%
Neutral (current zone)368−0.5%−0.4%−0.8%−1.6%
Distribution29−1.2%−2.1%−3.9%−5.6%
Selling9Too few readings yet

Average SIGI share-price change over the trading days after each daily reading in its GekkoIndex history. Across every stock Gekko tracks, Neutral readings averaged +0.9% over 20 days. Past behaviour doesn’t guarantee future results.

Neutral zone: No clear directional signal. About the five zones →

See every daily GekkoIndex reading plotted over the SIGI price, zone by zone.Track SIGI in Gekko

Is Selective Insurance stock overvalued? Gekko Fair Value

Selective Insurance trades 6.4% above Gekko Fair Value of $96.48, so the shares are overvalued on Gekko’s estimate.

Gekko’s own estimate of what Selective Insurance shares are worth, recalculated every trading day.

$96.48

Gekko Fair Value, Nov 14, 2026

6.4% Overvalued

At the end of Aug 2026 the price was 8.8% below the estimate.

Gekko Fair ValueShare price, month end
$96$103Aug 2026SepOctNov 2026

How Gekko Fair Value works →

Gekko Fair Value on every chart, with the gap to price updating daily.Open SIGI in Gekko

Selective Insurance insider and Congress trading

No open-market insider purchases were filed for Selective Insurance, and no Congress trades were disclosed, in the last 90 days.

Plus buybacks, unusual options and fund positions, each dated to when it became public.

Insider buying last 90 days

No open-market insider purchases were filed for SIGI in the last 90 days.

From Form 4 filings, dated to when each was filed.

Every SIGI insider filing, plotted on the chart in Gekko.Open SIGI in Gekko

Congress trades last 90 days

No trades in SIGI were disclosed by members of Congress in the last 90 days.

From congressional disclosures, which report amounts as ranges.

Congress disclosures for SIGI, plotted on the chart in Gekko.Open SIGI in Gekko

Buybacks

Selective Insurance has been buying back its own shares.

Latest authorization
$200.0M, Oct 22, 2026
Bought back, quarter ended Sep 30, 2026
$55.60M
As a share of market cap
0.91%
Trailing four quarters
$153.5M

From company filings.

Selective Insurance earnings: next date and track record

Selective Insurance reports on Feb 4, 2027, before the open (81 days away), and beat the EPS estimate in 2 of its last 8 reports.

2 of 8reports beat the EPS estimate
±8.1%average move across the report
1 of 8reports followed by a gain

Share-price move across each report

−5.7%May ’24−18.9%Jul ’24−5.4%Oct ’24−13.7%Jan ’25−2.3%Apr ’25−17.5%Jul ’25+0.5%Oct ’25−0.5%Jan ’26

Last earnings call, Jan 27, 2026 AI summary

What they said
Selective Insurance Group Q4 and Full Year 2025 earnings call. Management highlighted strong financial results: 2025 ROE 14.4% (operating 14.2%), book value per share up 18%, returned $182M to shareholders via dividends and buybacks. Net premiums written grew 5% for the year. Full-year combined ratio improved to 97.2% (Q4 93.8%), narrowly missing initial guidance but within updated range. Underwriting focus remains primary; strategic investments in geographic expansion, E&S distribution, data/analytics/AI and technology. Q4 drivers: favorable workers' compensation development offsetting unfavorable prior-year emergence in commercial & personal auto and E&S casualty. Management described reserve strengthening in 2024-25 with picks holding up. CFO reported EPS $2.52 GAAP (up 66% YoY), operating EPS $2.57 (up 59%), underlying combined ratio 92.1% for quarter, Standard Commercial Lines combined ratio 92.9% with higher current-year casualty loss costs, pricing increases across lines (GL +9.8%, commercial auto +8.6%, property renewal +12.2%). E&S combined ratio Q4 93.1% and 87.8% for year. Personal Lines combined ratio 103% (deterioration driven by catastrophe and New Jersey prior-year development). Guidance for 2026: underlying combined ratio 90.5%-91.5% (improvement vs 91.8% in 2025), embeds loss trend ~7.5% (3.5% property, 9% casualty), ~0.5 point higher expense ratio for tech investments, operating ROE ~14%. Management emphasized 100th anniversary, strategic priorities. Q&A covered reserves (workers' comp tail study, New Jersey concentrated PYD in personal auto), case reserve setting, E&S reserve $10M across 2020-2023, geographic expansion contributing 1-2 points growth historically, operating leverage target 1.35x-1.55x, capital discipline, retention stable around 82% though not guided, discussion on tech investments being ongoing and expect benefits over time.
Guidance
2026 guidance: underlying combined ratio 90.5%-91.5% (vs 91.8% in 2025). Embedded overall expected loss trend ~7.5% (property 3.5%, casualty 9%; casualty ~10% excluding workers' comp). Expense ratio expected to increase ~0.5 point due to strategic technology investments. Operating ROE implied in the 14% range for 2026. No segment-level combined ratio guidance provided.
Risks flagged
Risks discussed: reserving uncertainty from recent accident years (commercial auto, general liability, E&S casualty), concentrated prior-year development in New Jersey for personal auto, social inflation and pro-plaintiff legislative changes (NJ), deceleration in pricing particularly on property and some physical damage in commercial auto, market behavior affecting retention, potential upward pressure on medical severity in workers' comp, and pressure on growth in E&S if market pricing becomes aggressive. Also noted macro/market/interest rate assumptions impacting long-term investment yields.
ReportedEPSSurpriseRevenueSurpriseMove
Jan 27, 2026$2.57
est $2.13
+20.7%$1.13B
est $1.14B
−0.6%−0.5%
Oct 29, 2025$1.75
est $1.63
+7.4%$1.36B
est $1.35B
+0.8%+0.5%
Jul 23, 2025$1.31
est $1.55
−15.5%$1.33B
est $1.35B
−1.5%−17.5%
Apr 23, 2025$1.76
est $1.89
−6.9%$1.29B
est $1.31B
−1.7%−2.3%
Jan 29, 2025$1.62
est $1.99
−18.6%$1.26B
est $1.27B
−1.2%−13.7%
Oct 21, 2024$1.40
est $1.64
−14.6%$1.24B
est $1.09B
+14.5%−5.4%
Jul 18, 2024−$1.10
est $1.49
−173.8%$1.20B
est $1.17B
+2.2%−18.9%
May 2, 2024$1.33
est $1.86
−28.5%$1.16B
est $1.12B
+3.9%−5.7%

“Move” is the close of the first session after the report compared with the close of the last session before it, so it reads the same whether the company reported before the open or after the close.

Selective Insurance stock forecast and analyst price targets

Analysts’ average 12-month price target for Selective Insurance is $103.86, +1.2% from the last close, from 6 firms rating the stock in the last 90 days.

$103.86consensus 12-month target, +1.2% from the last close
Low $85High $115
Buy2
Hold3
Sell1

Each firm’s latest rating in the last 90 days: 6 firms.

Latest analyst actions

DateFirmRatingTargetvs price
Oct 27Morgan StanleySell, reiterated$85−17.2%
Oct 26KBWHold, maintained$105+2.3%
Oct 23Piper SandlerHold, maintained$97−5.5%
Oct 23RBC CapitalBuy, maintained$115+12.0%
Oct 20BMO CapitalHold, maintained$98−4.5%
−0.8%average 20-day move after past Neutral readings
+0.4%average move over the next 20 trading days in the last 5 years
±2.4%typical daily move, from the 14-day average range

Gekko doesn’t publish price predictions. These are analyst targets and historical base rates, which don’t guarantee future results.

Selective Insurance seasonality: the next 20 trading days

Over the next 20 trading days from Nov 14, Selective Insurance averaged +0.4% across the last 5 years, rising in 2 of them.

Next 20 trading days, by year

+3.1%2021−4.4%2022−0.1%2023−2.3%2024+6.8%2025

Average move and hit rate

WindowAverageYears higher
Next 5 trading days−1.1%1 of 5
Next 10 trading days−0.9%3 of 5
Next 15 trading days−0.6%2 of 5
Next 20 trading days+0.4%2 of 5
Next 30 trading days−0.7%2 of 5

For scale, SIGI’s typical 20-trading-day move in either direction is about 4.1%.

Selective Insurance market cap and key statistics

Selective Insurance’s market cap is $6.12B, with a P/E ratio of 12.4 and revenue of $5.44B over the last twelve months.

Valuation

Market cap
$6.12B
P/E ratio
12.4
Forward P/E
11.4
EPS, TTM
$8.32
Gekko Fair Value
$96.48

Trading

Volume
312,462
Avg volume, 20 days
587,142
52-week high
$105.65
52-week low
$72.78
Shares outstanding
59.57M

Financials

Revenue, TTM
$5.44B
Profit margin
9.4%
Return on equity
14.7%
Quarterly earnings growth, YoY
+14.1%

Risk and income

Beta
0.21
Typical daily move
±2.4%
Typical 20-day move
±4.1%
Dividend yield
1.67%

Selective Insurance stock news this week

Coverage of Selective Insurance this week reads neutral: 1 positive, 3 neutral and 0 negative headlines.

News sentiment neutral

Selective Insurance peers

Selective Insurance’s 6 largest industry peers by market value, with today’s move, GekkoIndex zone and gap to Gekko Fair Value.

StockTodayGekkoIndex zonevs Fair Value
BRK.ABerkshire Hathaway+0.2%Distribution10.8% above
BRK.BBerkshire Hathaway+0.1%Distribution9.8% above
CBChubb+0.1%Neutral4.8% above
TRVTravelers Companies−0.9%Neutral6.3% above
HIGHartford Insurance−0.4%Neutral0.1% below
MKLMarkel0.0%Neutral4.8% above

A peer links to its own page where one exists.

In the Buying zone today

Reporting earnings this week

Popular on Gekko

More stocks in Property/Casualty insurance

Selective Insurance stock FAQ

What is Selective Insurance’s market cap?

Selective Insurance’s market cap is $6.12B at the Nov 13, 2026 close of $102.67, with 59.57M shares outstanding. The shares trade on a P/E ratio of 12.4.

What is the Selective Insurance stock forecast?

The consensus analyst 12-month price target for Selective Insurance is $103.86, +1.2% from the last close. Of the 6 firms that rated the stock in the last 90 days, 2 rate it a buy, 3 a hold and 1 a sell. Gekko doesn’t publish price predictions of its own.

Is Selective Insurance stock overvalued or undervalued?

On Gekko’s estimate Selective Insurance is overvalued: the Nov 13, 2026 close of $102.67 is 6.4% above Gekko Fair Value of $96.48. Gekko Fair Value is recalculated every trading day, and a gap inside 5% either way counts as about fair value.

When does Selective Insurance report earnings next?

Selective Insurance is expected to report on Feb 4, 2027, before the market opens (81 days away). Analysts expect earnings of $2.68 per share on revenue of $1.07B. Selective Insurance beat the earnings estimate in 2 of its last 8 reports, moving 8.1% on average across the report.

What is Selective Insurance’s 52-week high and low?

Selective Insurance’s 52-week high is $105.65 and its 52-week low is $72.78; it closed at $102.67 on Nov 13, 2026, +29.8% over the past year. Over the last five years the shares peaked at $109.58 on Mar 28, 2024.

Is Selective Insurance stock a buy right now?

Gekko describes the data; it does not make buy or sell recommendations. On the swing-trade checklist, 2 of the 5 items with data read as supportive (trend and earnings risk), 2 as mixed (gekkoindex and seasonality) and 1 as a headwind (fair value). The checklist is a description of current data, not a recommendation.

How this page works

During US trading hours the price at the top of the page is a delayed quote, refreshed every 15 minutes; everything else is rebuilt after each US market close. The GekkoIndex, Gekko Fair Value and the checklist are Gekko’s own, and the Gekko Brief is written by AI from this page’s data and checked against it before it is published. How Gekko’s data works →

See Selective Insurance the way Gekko members do

Every GekkoIndex reading, insider trade, options bet and Congress disclosure plotted on the chart, plus the 5,800-name screener and trade planning tools.

Join 1,475 other traders using Gekko

Start Your FREE 7 Day Trial → Every feature unlocked. No credit card required.